4 Strategies to Identify a Good Short-Term Rental Property Management Company

Jerod McMurray • April 26, 2024

4 Strategies to Identify a Good Short-Term Rental Property Management Company


Looking for someone to help manage your short-term rental property? Do your homework before committing. 


Research different property management companies, ensure they're qualified, and determine if they fit your needs. Do background checks, assess and review their performance history, and carefully review their contracts.


Keep reading to learn the best strategies for finding a short-term rental property management company that looks out for your best interests and keeps your investment safe and successful.


Strategy #1: Do Your Market Research 


Performing due diligence when looking for a property manager helps you make informed decisions, mitigate risks, and maximize the success of your investment property. It's essential when selecting a property manager who can meet your needs and protect your interests. Here are some research tips:


  • Perform background checks on potential property management companies, including checking their reputation through reviews and ratings.
  • Verify credentials such as licenses, certifications, insurance, and affiliations with industry organizations.
  • Interview multiple property management companies to compare their services, fees, and experience.


Strategy #2: Assess Communication Styles


When selecting a property manager, assessing responsiveness can establish a working relationship built on trust, transparency, and collaboration. Excellent communication can help maximize your investment property's potential while minimizing stress and uncertainty. Start your assessment by:


  • Evaluating responsiveness to inquiries via phone, email, and online chat.
  • Determining availability for emergencies and how they handle guest issues, such as offering 24/7 support.
  • Asking for references to gauge communication and responsiveness.


Strategy #3: Review Performance Metrics


Reviewing performance metrics gives you insight into the success rates of property management companies. How they perform will determine how they maximize rental income, optimize guest satisfaction, and achieve long-term success with your short-term rental property. You can base your insights on: 


  • Performance metrics such as average daily rates, occupancy rates, and rental income
  • Guest satisfaction ratings or testimonials from previous guests to assess the quality of service
  • Case studies or success stories demonstrating how they’ve helped other property owners achieve their goals


Strategy #4: Clarify Contract Terms and Agreements


Understanding contract terms and agreements can empower you to establish clear expectations, protect interests, ensure legal compliance, manage risks, define services, facilitate communication, and provide flexibility in your property management relationship. Here are some ways to ensure mutual understanding:


  • Review contract terms and conditions thoroughly to confirm they align with your needs and expectations.
  • Clarify unclear terms regarding cancellation policies, payment procedures, and fees or charges.
  • Negotiate any contract changes you feel are necessary to protect your interests.


Are You a Rental Property Owner Looking to Partner with a Short-Term Property Management Company?


Aisling Baile uses proven processes to make your rental property a short-term rental success


We answer all your questions promptly, providing you with peace of mind, knowing you can sit back and collect passive income as we exceed your guests’ expectations by providing them — and you — unmatched service.


Ready to learn how to maximize your short-term rental?

Contact Us Today

Blog Content Topics

Recent Blog Posts

A man is stacking small houses on top of coins.
By Aisling Baile July 18, 2025
Discover how to set competitive short‑term rental rates in Calgary to maximize bookings and profits using dynamic pricing and local market insights.
Tubing along the Bow River in Calgary, Alberta.
July 16, 2025
Discover Calgary's hidden summer gems beyond the Stampede! Explore Bow River pathways, cultural hotspots, charming neighbourhoods, outdoor adventures & more.
How to Select the Best Short-Term Rental Management Company in Calgary
By Aisling Baile June 23, 2025
Choose the best short-term property management company in Calgary by evaluating services, fees & red flags. Book your free consultation with Aisling Baile today.
Show More